hasDissentingJustice
P4515
predicate
Indicates that within a judicial decision or ruling, there exists at least one justice who formally disagrees with the majority opinion.
All labels observed (8)
| Label | Occurrences |
|---|---|
| dissentingOpinionBy | 276 |
| hasDissentingJustice canonical | 30 |
| hasDissentingJustices | 15 |
| hasDissentFrom | 3 |
| hasDissentIn | 3 |
| joinedDissentBy | 3 |
| joinedKaganDissent | 1 |
| joinedScaliaDissent | 1 |
Description generation (PDg)
The one-sentence description above was generated by prompting gpt-5.1 with the predicate name and this instruction.
Instruction
Given a predicate that represents a relationship or action between entities, generate a one-sentence description explaining its meaning. # Instructions Focus on describing the relationship, not the entities themselves. # Response Format Begin the description with \' Indicates...\'
Input
Predicate: hasDissentingJustice
Generated description
Indicates that within a judicial decision or ruling, there exists at least one justice who formally disagrees with the majority opinion.
Sample triples (332)
| Subject | Object |
|---|---|
| New York Times Co. v. United States | John M. Harlan II via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy" ⓘ |
| New York Times Co. v. United States | Harry A. Blackmun via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy" ⓘ |
| Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission | John Paul Stevens via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy" ⓘ |
| Everson v. Board of Education | Justice Wiley B. Rutledge via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy" ⓘ |
| Everson v. Board of Education |
Felix Frankfurter
via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy"
ⓘ
surface form:
Justice Felix Frankfurter
|
| Everson v. Board of Education |
Robert H. Jackson
via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy"
ⓘ
surface form:
Justice Robert H. Jackson
|
| Everson v. Board of Education | Justice Frank Murphy via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy" ⓘ |
| Worcester v. Georgia | Henry Baldwin via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy" ⓘ |
| Worcester v. Georgia | William Johnson via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy" ⓘ |
| Van Orden v. Perry | John Paul Stevens via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy" ⓘ |
| Van Orden v. Perry | Sandra Day O’Connor via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy" ⓘ |
| Van Orden v. Perry | David H. Souter via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy" ⓘ |
| Van Orden v. Perry | Ruth Bader Ginsburg via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy" ⓘ |
| Santa Fe Independent School District v. Doe | William H. Rehnquist via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy" ⓘ |
| Dickerson v. United States | Antonin Scalia via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy" ⓘ |
| United States v. Morrison | David H. Souter via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy" ⓘ |
| United States v. Morrison | Stephen G. Breyer via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy" ⓘ |
| Abrams v. United States | Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr. via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy" ⓘ |
| Abrams v. United States |
Justice Louis D. Brandeis
via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy"
ⓘ
surface form:
Louis D. Brandeis
|
| South Carolina v. Katzenbach |
Hugo L. Black
ⓘ
surface form:
Hugo Black
|
| Betts v. Brady | Hugo L. Black via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy" ⓘ |
| Brnovich v. Democratic National Committee | Elena Kagan via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy" ⓘ |
| Hammer v. Dagenhart | Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr. via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy" ⓘ |
| Murdock v. Pennsylvania |
Felix Frankfurter
via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy"
ⓘ
surface form:
Justice Felix Frankfurter
|
| Murdock v. Pennsylvania |
Robert H. Jackson
via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy"
ⓘ
surface form:
Justice Robert H. Jackson
|
| Dartmouth College v. Woodward | William Johnson ⓘ |
| Dartmouth College v. Woodward | Brockholst Livingston ⓘ |
| Dartmouth College v. Woodward | Thomas Todd ⓘ |
| Frontiero v. Richardson | William H. Rehnquist via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy" ⓘ |
|
The Civil Rights Cases (1883)
surface form:
The Civil Rights Cases
|
John Marshall Harlan via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy" ⓘ |
|
Murphy v. National Collegiate Athletic Association (2018)
surface form:
Murphy v. National Collegiate Athletic Association
|
Ruth Bader Ginsburg via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy" ⓘ |
|
Murphy v. National Collegiate Athletic Association (2018)
surface form:
Murphy v. National Collegiate Athletic Association
|
Sonia Sotomayor via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy" ⓘ |
| Jay Printz, Sheriff/Coroner, Ravalli County, Montana, et al. v. United States | John Paul Stevens via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy" ⓘ |
| Jay Printz, Sheriff/Coroner, Ravalli County, Montana, et al. v. United States | David H. Souter via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy" ⓘ |
| Jay Printz, Sheriff/Coroner, Ravalli County, Montana, et al. v. United States | Ruth Bader Ginsburg via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy" ⓘ |
| Jay Printz, Sheriff/Coroner, Ravalli County, Montana, et al. v. United States | Stephen G. Breyer via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy" ⓘ |
| California v. Texas |
Samuel A. Alito Jr.
via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy"
ⓘ
surface form:
Samuel A. Alito, Jr.
|
| King v. Burwell | Antonin Scalia via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy" ⓘ |
| Buck v. Bell opinion | Pierce Butler ⓘ |
| Palsgraf v. Long Island Railroad Co. | William S. Andrews via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy" ⓘ |
| Cannon v. University of Chicago |
Lewis F. Powell Jr.
via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy"
ⓘ
surface form:
Justice Lewis F. Powell Jr.
|
| Cannon v. University of Chicago |
William H. Rehnquist
via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy"
ⓘ
surface form:
Justice William H. Rehnquist
|
| Cannon v. University of Chicago |
Warren E. Burger
via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy"
ⓘ
surface form:
Justice Warren E. Burger
|
| Cannon v. University of Chicago |
William J. Brennan Jr.
via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy"
ⓘ
surface form:
Justice William J. Brennan Jr.
|
| Davis v. Monroe County Board of Education |
Anthony M. Kennedy
via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy"
ⓘ
surface form:
Justice Anthony M. Kennedy
|
| Davis v. Monroe County Board of Education |
William H. Rehnquist
via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy"
ⓘ
surface form:
Justice William H. Rehnquist
|
| Davis v. Monroe County Board of Education |
Antonin Scalia
via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy"
ⓘ
surface form:
Justice Antonin Scalia
|
| Davis v. Monroe County Board of Education |
Clarence Thomas
via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy"
ⓘ
surface form:
Justice Clarence Thomas
|
| Seminole Tribe of Florida v. Florida | John Paul Stevens via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy" ⓘ |
| Seminole Tribe of Florida v. Florida | David H. Souter via predicate surface "dissentingOpinionBy" ⓘ |