standardOfReview
P3850
predicate
Indicates the level and type of scrutiny an authority (such as a court or reviewer) applies when evaluating a prior decision, action, or finding.
All labels observed (12)
| Label | Occurrences |
|---|---|
| standardOfReview canonical | 89 |
| typeOfReview | 57 |
| reviewStandard | 22 |
| typeOfScrutiny | 8 |
| appliedStandardOfReview | 4 |
| hasStandardOfReview | 3 |
| appliesStandardOfReview | 2 |
| standardOfReviewDiscussed | 2 |
| discretionStandard | 1 |
| standardOfReviewEstablished | 1 |
| standardOfReviewOnAppeal | 1 |
| standardOfReviewOutcome | 1 |
Sample triples (191)
| Subject | Object |
|---|---|
| United States v. Virginia (1996) majority opinion | heightened scrutiny ⓘ |
| United States v. Virginia (1996) majority opinion | intermediate scrutiny ⓘ |
| Church of the Lukumi Babalu Aye v. City of Hialeah | strict scrutiny ⓘ |
| Benefits Review Board | substantial evidence for factual findings ⓘ |
| Benefits Review Board | de novo review of legal questions ⓘ |
|
SJC
surface form:
Supreme Judicial Court
|
appellate review via predicate surface "typeOfReview" ⓘ |
| Administrative Procedure Act | arbitrary and capricious standard ⓘ |
| Administrative Procedure Act | substantial evidence standard ⓘ |
| Administrative Procedure Act | de novo review in limited circumstances ⓘ |
| San Antonio Independent School District v. Rodriguez | rational basis review ⓘ |
| Employees’ Compensation Appeals Board | review of decisions of the Office of Workers’ Compensation Programs via predicate surface "reviewStandard" ⓘ |
| Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court | probable cause that the target is a foreign power or agent of a foreign power ⓘ |
| Craig v. Boren | intermediate scrutiny via predicate surface "standardOfReviewEstablished" ⓘ |
| Mississippi University for Women v. Hogan | intermediate scrutiny ⓘ |
| Reed v. Reed | rational basis review via predicate surface "appliedStandardOfReview" ⓘ |
|
Environment Committee
surface form:
Environment Committee (London Assembly)
|
thematic scrutiny via predicate surface "typeOfScrutiny" ⓘ |
| Italian Constitutional Court | constitutional review of laws via predicate surface "typeOfReview" ⓘ |
| Constitutional Court of Chile | a priori constitutional review in some procedures via predicate surface "typeOfReview" ⓘ |
| Constitutional Court of Chile | a posteriori constitutional review in some procedures via predicate surface "typeOfReview" ⓘ |
| Fisher v. University of Texas at Austin | strict scrutiny ⓘ |
| Lemon test | constitutional scrutiny under the Establishment Clause via predicate surface "appliesStandardOfReview" ⓘ |
| Sherbert test | strict scrutiny ⓘ |
|
APA
surface form:
Administrative Procedure Act
|
arbitrary and capricious standard ⓘ |
|
APA
surface form:
Administrative Procedure Act
|
substantial evidence standard ⓘ |
|
APA
surface form:
Administrative Procedure Act
|
review for abuse of discretion ⓘ |
|
APA
surface form:
Administrative Procedure Act
|
review for contrary to law ⓘ |
| Public Law 106-274 | strict scrutiny for substantial burdens on religious exercise ⓘ |
| Committee against Torture | treaty body review via predicate surface "typeOfReview" ⓘ |
| Criminal Cases Review Commission | post-conviction review via predicate surface "typeOfReview" ⓘ |
|
Constitutional Court of Colombia (which handles constitutional review)
surface form:
Constitutional Court of Colombia
|
abstract review of constitutionality via predicate surface "typeOfReview" ⓘ |
|
Constitutional Court of Colombia (which handles constitutional review)
surface form:
Constitutional Court of Colombia
|
concrete review of constitutionality via predicate surface "typeOfReview" ⓘ |
| Plyler v. Doe | heightened rational basis scrutiny via predicate surface "hasStandardOfReview" ⓘ |
| Thomas v. Review Board of the Indiana Employment Security Division | strict scrutiny ⓘ |
| Constitutional Oversight Committee of the USSR | abstract constitutional review via predicate surface "typeOfReview" ⓘ |
| Patent Trial and Appeal Board | administrative review of patentability via predicate surface "typeOfReview" ⓘ |
| WTO panels | objective assessment of the matter before it ⓘ |
| CAAF | discretionary review in most cases via predicate surface "typeOfReview" ⓘ |
| CAAF | mandatory review in certain death penalty cases via predicate surface "typeOfReview" ⓘ |
| Army Court of Criminal Appeals | mandatory review of qualifying courts-martial via predicate surface "typeOfReview" ⓘ |
| Army Court of Criminal Appeals | direct appeal via predicate surface "typeOfReview" ⓘ |
| Army Court of Criminal Appeals | de novo review of legal issues ⓘ |
| Army Court of Criminal Appeals | de novo review of factual sufficiency ⓘ |
| District of Kansas Bankruptcy Appellate Panel | de novo review for legal conclusions via predicate surface "reviewStandard" ⓘ |
| District of Kansas Bankruptcy Appellate Panel | clear error review for factual findings via predicate surface "reviewStandard" ⓘ |
| District of Kansas Bankruptcy Appellate Panel | abuse of discretion review for certain rulings via predicate surface "reviewStandard" ⓘ |
| Frontiero v. Richardson | strict scrutiny for sex-based classifications via predicate surface "standardOfReviewDiscussed" ⓘ |
| Frontiero v. Richardson | no single standard of review commanded a majority via predicate surface "standardOfReviewOutcome" ⓘ |
| Romer v. Evans | rational basis review via predicate surface "standardOfReviewDiscussed" ⓘ |
|
Rule 72
surface form:
Rule 72(a)
|
clearly erroneous or contrary to law ⓘ |
|
Rule 72
surface form:
Rule 72(b)
|
de novo review ⓘ |