legalDoctrineChallenged
P15326
predicate
Indicates that a particular legal doctrine is being disputed, questioned, or contested, typically through litigation or formal legal argument.
All labels observed (5)
| Label | Occurrences |
|---|---|
| legalArgument | 25 |
| legalIssueRaised | 8 |
| legalBasisContested | 2 |
| legalDoctrineChallenged canonical | 2 |
| legalArgumentPositionInDobbs | 1 |
Description generation (PDg)
The one-sentence description above was generated by prompting gpt-5.1 with the predicate name and this instruction.
Instruction
Given a predicate that represents a relationship or action between entities, generate a one-sentence description explaining its meaning. # Instructions Focus on describing the relationship, not the entities themselves. # Response Format Begin the description with \' Indicates...\'
Input
Predicate: legalDoctrineChallenged
Generated description
Indicates that a particular legal doctrine is being disputed, questioned, or contested, typically through litigation or formal legal argument.
Sample triples (38)
| Subject | Object |
|---|---|
| Davis v. County School Board of Prince Edward County | separate but equal ⓘ |
|
Alfonso Lopez, Jr.
surface form:
Alfonso Lopez Jr.
|
scope of the Commerce Clause via predicate surface "legalIssueRaised" ⓘ |
|
Alfonso Lopez, Jr.
surface form:
Alfonso Lopez Jr.
|
limits on congressional power under the Commerce Clause via predicate surface "legalIssueRaised" ⓘ |
| Gebhart v. Belton | separate but equal ⓘ |
| The Selling of Joseph | questions legality of perpetual servitude in Massachusetts via predicate surface "legalArgument" ⓘ |
| Joe G. Garcia | application of federal wage and hour laws to state employees via predicate surface "legalIssueRaised" ⓘ |
| Joe G. Garcia | coverage of state and local government employees under the Fair Labor Standards Act via predicate surface "legalIssueRaised" ⓘ |
| Southern Manifesto | states’ rights via predicate surface "legalArgument" ⓘ |
| Southern Manifesto | doctrine of interposition via predicate surface "legalArgument" ⓘ |
| Ronald H. Bradley et al. | scope of permissible interdistrict desegregation remedies via predicate surface "legalIssueRaised" ⓘ |
| Dred Scott | residence in free territory made him free via predicate surface "legalArgument" ⓘ |
| Dutch East India Company prize case of the Santa Catarina | the seas cannot be appropriated by any single power via predicate surface "legalArgument" ⓘ |
| Dutch East India Company prize case of the Santa Catarina | Dutch had a just war against the Portuguese in Asia via predicate surface "legalArgument" ⓘ |
| Dutch East India Company prize case of the Santa Catarina | private merchants could lawfully seize enemy goods under sovereign commission via predicate surface "legalArgument" ⓘ |
| Dutch East India Company prize case of the Santa Catarina | Portuguese monopoly in the East Indies trade was illegitimate via predicate surface "legalArgument" ⓘ |
| Sharp’s case against slavery in England | slavery is unsupported by English common law via predicate surface "legalArgument" ⓘ |
| Sharp’s case against slavery in England | slavery cannot exist without positive law via predicate surface "legalArgument" ⓘ |
| Sharp’s case against slavery in England | English law presumes personal liberty via predicate surface "legalArgument" ⓘ |
| The Constitutional Rights of the Women of the United States | women are entitled to vote under the U.S. Constitution via predicate surface "legalArgument" ⓘ |
| The Constitutional Rights of the Women of the United States | women are citizens under the Fourteenth Amendment via predicate surface "legalArgument" ⓘ |
| The Constitutional Rights of the Women of the United States | citizenship implies political rights via predicate surface "legalArgument" ⓘ |
| The Constitutional Rights of the Women of the United States | denial of women's suffrage is unconstitutional via predicate surface "legalArgument" ⓘ |
|
Mississippi Attorney General Lynn Fitch
surface form:
Lynn Fitch
|
Roe v. Wade should be overturned via predicate surface "legalArgumentPositionInDobbs" ⓘ |
| Standing Bear | Native Americans are persons under U.S. law via predicate surface "legalArgument" NERFINISHED ⓘ |
| Standing Bear | Native Americans have the right to choose where to live via predicate surface "legalArgument" ⓘ |
| Snowden leaks | Section 215 of the USA PATRIOT Act via predicate surface "legalBasisContested" ⓘ |
| Snowden leaks | Section 702 of the FISA Amendments Act via predicate surface "legalBasisContested" NERFINISHED ⓘ |
| Letter IX | Parliament has no right to tax the colonies without their consent via predicate surface "legalArgument" ⓘ |
| Letter IX | colonists are entitled to the rights of Englishmen via predicate surface "legalArgument" ⓘ |
| Letter to Queen Victoria (1839) regarding the opium trade | opium importation violates Chinese law via predicate surface "legalArgument" ⓘ |
| Letter to Queen Victoria (1839) regarding the opium trade | foreigners in China must obey Chinese laws via predicate surface "legalArgument" ⓘ |
| Ruchell Magee | described himself as a political prisoner via predicate surface "legalArgument" ⓘ |
| Ruchell Magee | challenged the legitimacy of his prosecution via predicate surface "legalArgument" ⓘ |
| George H. Eldridge | due process protections in termination of disability benefits via predicate surface "legalIssueRaised" ⓘ |
| George H. Eldridge | requirement of evidentiary hearing before termination of Social Security disability benefits via predicate surface "legalIssueRaised" ⓘ |
| Pentagon Papers litigation | national security risk via predicate surface "legalArgument" ⓘ |
| Pentagon Papers litigation | First Amendment protection of press freedom via predicate surface "legalArgument" ⓘ |
| Humberto Munoz-Flores | constitutionality of a federal statute under the Origination Clause via predicate surface "legalIssueRaised" ⓘ |