Balzac v. Porto Rico

E388980

Balzac v. Porto Rico is a 1922 U.S. Supreme Court decision that held certain constitutional rights, including the right to a jury trial, do not automatically apply in unincorporated territories such as Puerto Rico.

All labels observed (1)

Label Occurrences
Balzac v. Porto Rico canonical 10

How this entity was disambiguated

Statements (49)

Predicate Object
instanceOf Insular Cases decision ⓘ
United States Supreme Court case ⓘ
federal courts case ⓘ
appliesDoctrine Insular Cases ⓘ
surface form: Insular Cases doctrine
areaOfLaw United States constitutional law ⓘ
United States territorial law ⓘ
criminal procedure in U.S. territories ⓘ
authorOfMajorityOpinion President William Howard Taft ⓘ
surface form: William Howard Taft
ChiefJusticeAtDecision President William Howard Taft ⓘ
surface form: William Howard Taft
citation 258 U.S. 298 ⓘ
clarifies distinction between incorporated and unincorporated territories ⓘ
concerns application of the United States Constitution in unincorporated territories ⓘ
right to trial by jury ⓘ
status of Puerto Rico as an unincorporated territory ⓘ
constitutionalProvisionInterpreted Article III of the United States Constitution ⓘ
Territorial Clause of the United States Constitution ⓘ
surface form: Article IV Territorial Clause of the United States Constitution

U.S. Constitution, Sixth Amendment ⓘ
surface form: Sixth Amendment to the United States Constitution
country United States of America ⓘ
surface form: United States
court Supreme Court of the United States ⓘ
decisionDate 1922-04-10 ⓘ
decisionType unanimous decision ⓘ
fullCaseName Balzac v. Porto Rico self-link ⓘ
hasJurisdiction Supreme Court of the United States ⓘ
holding Not all provisions of the United States Constitution apply ex proprio vigore to unincorporated territories ⓘ
Puerto Rico is an unincorporated territory of the United States for constitutional purposes ⓘ
The Sixth Amendment right to a jury trial in criminal prosecutions does not automatically apply in unincorporated territories such as Puerto Rico ⓘ
impact limited the automatic extension of certain constitutional rights to residents of unincorporated territories ⓘ
reinforced classification of Puerto Rico as unincorporated for constitutional purposes ⓘ
involves criminal libel prosecution ⓘ
languageOfProceedings English ⓘ
legalEffect binding precedent on federal courts regarding constitutional rights in unincorporated territories ⓘ
legalSubject constitutional law ⓘ
criminal procedure ⓘ
territorial law ⓘ
locationOfFacts Puerto Rico ⓘ
majorityOpinionBy President William Howard Taft ⓘ
surface form: William Howard Taft
pageInUnitedStatesReports 298 ⓘ
party Honoré de Balzac ⓘ
surface form: Balzac

Puerto Rico ⓘ
surface form: Porto Rico
relatedCase Dorr v. United States ⓘ
Downes v. Bidwell ⓘ
Hawaii v. Mankichi ⓘ
Rassmussen v. United States ⓘ
relatedDoctrine territorial incorporation doctrine ⓘ
result conviction in Puerto Rican court affirmed ⓘ
territory Puerto Rico ⓘ
territoryStatusConsidered unincorporated territory ⓘ
volumeInUnitedStatesReports 258 ⓘ
yearDecided 1922 ⓘ

How these facts were elicited

Referenced by (10)

Full triples — surface form annotated when it differs from this entity's canonical label.

insular cases doctrine → hasPart → Balzac v. Porto Rico ⓘ
subject surface form: Insular Cases doctrine
United States territorial law → shapedBy → Balzac v. Porto Rico ⓘ
Balzac v. Porto Rico → fullCaseName → Balzac v. Porto Rico self-link ⓘ
Insular Cases → hasPart → Balzac v. Porto Rico ⓘ
Insular Cases → notableCase → Balzac v. Porto Rico ⓘ
Dooley v. United States → isRelatedCase → Balzac v. Porto Rico ⓘ
Dorr v. United States → relatedCase → Balzac v. Porto Rico ⓘ
Dorr v. United States → subsequentInfluenceOn → Balzac v. Porto Rico ⓘ
Ocampo v. United States → relatedTo → Balzac v. Porto Rico ⓘ