dissentingJustice

P4522 predicate

Indicates that a particular justice disagrees with the majority opinion or decision in a legal case.

Aliases (14)
  • dissentBy ×87
  • dissentingJustices ×27
  • hasDissentBy ×17
  • joinedDissent ×8
  • joinedByInDissent ×6
  • justiceInDissent ×6
  • separateOpinionBy ×5
  • dissentJoinedBy ×4
  • hasJusticeInDissent ×4
  • dissentOpinionBy ×3
  • dissentingJoiner ×3
  • hasDissentingOpinionBy ×3
  • dissenting ×1
  • voteDissent ×1

Sample triples (217)
Subject Object
Alabama v. Shelton Anthony M. Kennedy ("hasDissentBy") NERFINISHED
Alabama v. Shelton Antonin Scalia ("hasDissentBy") NERFINISHED
Alabama v. Shelton Clarence Thomas ("hasDissentBy") NERFINISHED
Alabama v. Shelton William H. Rehnquist ("hasDissentBy")
American Insurance Assn. v. Garamendi Antonin Scalia ("dissentingJoiner")
American Insurance Assn. v. Garamendi John Paul Stevens ("dissentingJoiner")
American Insurance Assn. v. Garamendi Stephen G. Breyer ("dissentingJoiner")
Baldwin v. Fish and Game Commission of Montana John Paul Stevens ("dissentingJustices")
Baldwin v. Fish and Game Commission of Montana William H. Rehnquist ("dissentingJustices")
Betts v. Brady Frank Murphy ("dissentingJustices")
Betts v. Brady Hugo L. Black ("dissentingJustices")
Betts v. Brady William O. Douglas ("dissentingJustices") NERFINISHED
Bostock v. Clayton County Clarence Thomas ("dissentJoinedBy")
Brnovich v. Democratic National Committee Sonia Sotomayor ("joinedByInDissent")
Brnovich v. Democratic National Committee Stephen G. Breyer ("joinedByInDissent") NERFINISHED
Burwell v. Hobby Lobby Stores, Inc. Ruth Bader Ginsburg ("dissentBy")
Bush v. Gore David H. Souter
Bush v. Gore John Paul Stevens
Bush v. Gore Ruth Bader Ginsburg
Bush v. Gore Stephen G. Breyer
California v. Texas Neil M. Gorsuch ("dissentJoinedBy")
Cheney v. U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia David H. Souter ("dissentBy")
Cheney v. U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia John Paul Stevens ("dissentBy")
Cheney v. U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia Ruth Bader Ginsburg ("dissentBy")
Cheney v. U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia Stephen G. Breyer ("dissentBy")
Cherokee Nation v. Georgia Henry Baldwin
Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission Antonin Scalia ("separateOpinionBy") NERFINISHED
Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission Clarence Thomas ("separateOpinionBy") NERFINISHED
Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission John G. Roberts ("separateOpinionBy") NERFINISHED
Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission Ruth Bader Ginsburg ("joinedDissent")
Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission Sonia Sotomayor ("joinedDissent")
Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission Stephen Breyer ("joinedDissent") NERFINISHED
City of Boerne v. Flores David H. Souter ("dissentBy") NERFINISHED
City of Boerne v. Flores Sandra Day O’Connor ("dissentBy")
City of Boerne v. Flores Stephen G. Breyer ("dissentBy") NERFINISHED
Craig v. Boren Harry A. Blackmun ("dissentBy")
Craig v. Boren Warren E. Burger ("dissentBy")
Craig v. Boren William H. Rehnquist ("dissentBy")
Dickerson v. United States Clarence Thomas ("joinedByInDissent") NERFINISHED
Doe v. Bolton Byron R. White
Doe v. Bolton William H. Rehnquist
Employment Division v. Smith Harry Blackmun ("hasDissentBy")
Employment Division v. Smith Thurgood Marshall ("hasDissentBy")
Employment Division v. Smith William J. Brennan Jr. ("hasDissentBy")
Engel v. Vitale Potter Stewart NERFINISHED
Escobedo v. Illinois Byron R. White ("dissentBy") NERFINISHED
Escobedo v. Illinois John M. Harlan II ("dissentBy")
Escobedo v. Illinois Potter Stewart ("dissentBy") NERFINISHED
Escobedo v. Illinois Tom C. Clark ("dissentBy")
FCC v. Pacifica Foundation Potter Stewart ("dissentBy") NERFINISHED
FCC v. Pacifica Foundation Thurgood Marshall ("dissentBy")
FCC v. Pacifica Foundation William H. Rehnquist ("dissentBy")
FCC v. Pacifica Foundation William J. Brennan Jr. ("dissentBy") NERFINISHED
Fisher v. University of Texas at Austin Ruth Bader Ginsburg ("dissentBy")
Furman v. Georgia Harry A. Blackmun ("justiceInDissent")
Furman v. Georgia Lewis F. Powell Jr. ("justiceInDissent")
Furman v. Georgia Warren E. Burger ("justiceInDissent")
Furman v. Georgia William H. Rehnquist ("justiceInDissent")
Gitlow v. New York Louis D. Brandeis ("hasDissentBy")
Gitlow v. New York Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr. ("hasDissentBy")
Gonzales v. Raich Clarence Thomas ("dissentBy")
Gonzales v. Raich Sandra Day O’Connor ("dissentBy")
Gonzales v. Raich William H. Rehnquist ("dissentBy")
Gratz v. Bollinger David H. Souter NERFINISHED
Gratz v. Bollinger John Paul Stevens NERFINISHED
Gratz v. Bollinger Ruth Bader Ginsburg
Gregg v. Georgia Thurgood Marshall ("dissentBy")
Gregg v. Georgia William J. Brennan Jr. ("dissentBy") NERFINISHED
Grutter v. Bollinger Anthony M. Kennedy ("dissentBy") NERFINISHED
Grutter v. Bollinger Antonin Scalia ("dissentBy") NERFINISHED
Grutter v. Bollinger Clarence Thomas ("dissentBy") NERFINISHED
Grutter v. Bollinger William H. Rehnquist ("dissentBy")
Hammer v. Dagenhart John H. Clarke ("joinedByInDissent") NERFINISHED
Hammer v. Dagenhart Joseph McKenna ("joinedByInDissent")
Hammer v. Dagenhart Louis D. Brandeis ("joinedByInDissent")
Harper v. Virginia Board of Elections Hugo L. Black ("hasDissentingOpinionBy") NERFINISHED
Harper v. Virginia Board of Elections John Marshall Harlan II ("hasDissentingOpinionBy") NERFINISHED
Hobbie v. Unemployment Appeals Commission of Florida John Paul Stevens ("dissentBy") NERFINISHED
INS v. Chadha Justice Byron R. White ("dissentBy")
INS v. Chadha Justice William H. Rehnquist ("dissentBy")
Katzenbach v. Morgan Byron R. White ("dissentBy") NERFINISHED
Katzenbach v. Morgan John M. Harlan II ("dissentBy") NERFINISHED
Katzenbach v. Morgan Potter Stewart ("dissentBy") NERFINISHED
King v. Burwell Antonin Scalia ("dissentingJustices") NERFINISHED
King v. Burwell Clarence Thomas ("dissentingJustices") NERFINISHED
King v. Burwell Samuel A. Alito, Jr. ("dissentingJustices") NERFINISHED
Korematsu v. United States Frank Murphy ("dissentingJustices")
Korematsu v. United States Owen J. Roberts ("dissentingJustices") NERFINISHED
Korematsu v. United States Robert H. Jackson ("dissentingJustices") NERFINISHED
Lawrence v. Texas Antonin Scalia ("dissentBy") NERFINISHED
Lawrence v. Texas Clarence Thomas ("dissentBy") NERFINISHED
Lawrence v. Texas William H. Rehnquist ("dissentBy")
Lee v. Weisman Antonin Scalia ("dissentBy") NERFINISHED
Lee v. Weisman Byron R. White ("joinedDissent") NERFINISHED
Lee v. Weisman Clarence Thomas ("joinedDissent") NERFINISHED
Lee v. Weisman William H. Rehnquist ("joinedDissent")
Lochner v. New York Edward Douglass White ("dissentBy")
Lochner v. New York John Marshall Harlan ("dissentBy")
Lochner v. New York Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr. ("dissentBy")
Lochner v. New York William R. Day ("dissentBy") NERFINISHED
Lynch v. Donnelly Justice Harry A. Blackmun ("hasDissentBy") NERFINISHED
Lynch v. Donnelly Justice John Paul Stevens ("hasDissentBy") NERFINISHED
Lynch v. Donnelly Justice Thurgood Marshall ("hasDissentBy")
Lynch v. Donnelly Justice William J. Brennan Jr. ("hasDissentBy") NERFINISHED
Mapp v. Ohio Byron R. White ("dissentBy")
Mapp v. Ohio Charles E. Whittaker ("dissentBy")
Mapp v. Ohio Felix Frankfurter ("dissentBy")
Mapp v. Ohio John M. Harlan II ("dissentBy")
Masterpiece Cakeshop v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission Ruth Bader Ginsburg ("justiceInDissent")
Masterpiece Cakeshop v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission Ruth Bader Ginsburg ("dissentBy")
Masterpiece Cakeshop v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission Sonia Sotomayor ("justiceInDissent")
Masterpiece Cakeshop v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission Sonia Sotomayor ("dissentJoinedBy")
Morgan v. Virginia Justice Harold Hitz Burton ("dissentBy") NERFINISHED
Morgan v. Virginia Justice Robert H. Jackson (did not participate in majority) ("dissentBy")
NFIB v. Sebelius Ruth Bader Ginsburg ("separateOpinionBy")
NFIB v. Sebelius Stephen G. Breyer ("separateOpinionBy")
NLRB v. Jones & Laughlin Steel Corp. George Sutherland
NLRB v. Jones & Laughlin Steel Corp. James C. McReynolds
NLRB v. Jones & Laughlin Steel Corp. Pierce Butler
NLRB v. Jones & Laughlin Steel Corp. Willis Van Devanter
New York Times Co. v. United States Harry A. Blackmun NERFINISHED
New York Times Co. v. United States John M. Harlan II
New York Times Co. v. United States Warren E. Burger
Obergefell v. Hodges 4 ("voteDissent")
Palko v. Connecticut George Sutherland
Palko v. Connecticut James C. McReynolds
Palko v. Connecticut Pierce Butler
Palko v. Connecticut Willis Van Devanter
Parents Involved in Community Schools v. Seattle School District No. 1 John Paul Stevens ("dissentBy")
Parents Involved in Community Schools v. Seattle School District No. 1 Stephen G. Breyer ("dissentBy")
Planned Parenthood v. Casey Antonin Scalia ("dissentBy")
Planned Parenthood v. Casey Byron R. White ("dissentBy")
Planned Parenthood v. Casey Clarence Thomas ("dissentBy")
Planned Parenthood v. Casey William H. Rehnquist ("dissentBy")
Plyler v. Doe Byron R. White ("hasDissentBy") NERFINISHED
Plyler v. Doe Sandra Day O'Connor ("hasDissentBy")
Plyler v. Doe Warren E. Burger ("hasDissentBy")
Plyler v. Doe William H. Rehnquist ("hasDissentBy")
Price Waterhouse v. Hopkins Anthony M. Kennedy ("dissentBy")
Price Waterhouse v. Hopkins Byron R. White ("dissentBy")
Price Waterhouse v. Hopkins Sandra Day O'Connor ("dissentBy")
Price Waterhouse v. Hopkins William H. Rehnquist ("dissentBy")
Printz v. United States David H. Souter ("dissentBy")
Printz v. United States John Paul Stevens ("dissentBy")
Printz v. United States Ruth Bader Ginsburg ("dissentBy")
Printz v. United States Stephen G. Breyer ("dissentBy")
Regents of the University of California v. Bakke John Paul Stevens ("dissentBy")
Regents of the University of California v. Bakke Potter Stewart ("dissentBy")
Regents of the University of California v. Bakke Warren E. Burger ("dissentBy")
Regents of the University of California v. Bakke William H. Rehnquist ("dissentBy")
Romer v. Evans Antonin Scalia ("dissentingJustices") NERFINISHED
Romer v. Evans Antonin Scalia ("dissentOpinionBy") NERFINISHED
Romer v. Evans Clarence Thomas ("dissentingJustices") NERFINISHED
Romer v. Evans William H. Rehnquist ("dissentingJustices")
Santa Fe Independent School District v. Doe Antonin Scalia ("dissentingJustices") NERFINISHED
Santa Fe Independent School District v. Doe Clarence Thomas ("dissentingJustices") NERFINISHED
Santa Fe Independent School District v. Doe William H. Rehnquist ("dissentingJustices")
Shaw v. Reno Byron R. White ("dissentBy") NERFINISHED
Shaw v. Reno David H. Souter ("dissentBy") NERFINISHED
Shaw v. Reno Harry A. Blackmun ("dissentBy") NERFINISHED
Shaw v. Reno John Paul Stevens ("dissentBy") NERFINISHED
Shelby County v. Holder Elena Kagan ("hasJusticeInDissent")
Shelby County v. Holder Ruth Bader Ginsburg ("hasJusticeInDissent")
Shelby County v. Holder Ruth Bader Ginsburg ("hasDissentingOpinionBy")
Shelby County v. Holder Sonia Sotomayor ("hasJusticeInDissent")
Shelby County v. Holder Stephen G. Breyer ("hasJusticeInDissent")
Sherbert v. Verner Byron R. White ("dissentBy")
Sherbert v. Verner John Marshall Harlan II ("dissentBy")
Smith v. Allwright Owen J. Roberts ("dissentBy")
South Dakota v. Dole Sandra Day O’Connor ("dissentBy")
Steward Machine Co. v. Davis Justice George Sutherland
Steward Machine Co. v. Davis Justice James C. McReynolds
Steward Machine Co. v. Davis Justice Pierce Butler
Steward Machine Co. v. Davis Justice Willis Van Devanter
Supreme Court of New Hampshire v. Piper Justice William H. Rehnquist
Thomas v. Review Board of the Indiana Employment Security Division Justice John Paul Stevens ("dissentBy") NERFINISHED
Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District Hugo Black ("dissentBy")
Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District John M. Harlan II ("dissentBy")
Town of Greece v. Galloway Elena Kagan ("dissentBy")
Town of Greece v. Galloway Ruth Bader Ginsburg ("dissentBy")
Town of Greece v. Galloway Sonia Sotomayor ("dissentBy")
Town of Greece v. Galloway Stephen G. Breyer ("dissentBy") NERFINISHED
Trump v. Mazars USA, LLP Samuel A. Alito, Jr. ("dissenting") NERFINISHED
Trump v. Vance Clarence Thomas ("dissentingJustices")
Trump v. Vance Clarence Thomas ("dissentOpinionBy")
Trump v. Vance Samuel A. Alito Jr. ("dissentingJustices")
Trump v. Vance Samuel A. Alito Jr. ("dissentOpinionBy")
United Public Workers v. Mitchell Frank Murphy
United Public Workers v. Mitchell Hugo L. Black NERFINISHED
United Public Workers v. Mitchell William O. Douglas NERFINISHED
United States v. Comstock Antonin Scalia ("dissentJoinedBy")
United States v. Comstock Clarence Thomas ("dissentBy")
United States v. Morrison John Paul Stevens ("joinedDissent") NERFINISHED
United States v. Morrison Ruth Bader Ginsburg ("joinedDissent")
Village of Arlington Heights v. Metropolitan Housing Development Corp. Byron R. White NERFINISHED
Village of Arlington Heights v. Metropolitan Housing Development Corp. Thurgood Marshall
Village of Arlington Heights v. Metropolitan Housing Development Corp. William J. Brennan Jr. NERFINISHED
West Virginia State Board of Education v. Barnette Felix Frankfurter
West Virginia State Board of Education v. Barnette Owen J. Roberts
West Virginia State Board of Education v. Barnette Stanley Reed
Windsor v. United States (in part) Antonin Scalia NERFINISHED
Windsor v. United States (in part) Clarence Thomas NERFINISHED
Windsor v. United States (in part) John G. Roberts, Jr. NERFINISHED
Windsor v. United States (in part) Samuel A. Alito, Jr. NERFINISHED
Wolf v. Colorado Frank Murphy ("dissentBy")
Wolf v. Colorado Robert H. Jackson ("dissentBy")
Wolf v. Colorado William O. Douglas ("dissentBy") NERFINISHED
Yamashita v. Styer Justice Frank Murphy
Yamashita v. Styer Justice Wiley B. Rutledge
Zelman v. Simmons-Harris David H. Souter ("dissentingJustices") NERFINISHED
Zelman v. Simmons-Harris John Paul Stevens ("dissentingJustices") NERFINISHED
Zelman v. Simmons-Harris Ruth Bader Ginsburg ("dissentingJustices")
Zelman v. Simmons-Harris Stephen G. Breyer ("dissentingJustices") NERFINISHED
opinion in Texas v. Johnson Byron R. White ("dissentingJustices")
opinion in Texas v. Johnson John Paul Stevens ("dissentingJustices")
opinion in Texas v. Johnson Sandra Day O’Connor ("dissentingJustices")
opinion in Texas v. Johnson William H. Rehnquist ("dissentingJustices")

Please wait…