hasDisputedIdentityWith

P13304
predicate

Indicates that two entities are associated with conflicting, uncertain, or contested identifications, such that their true or correct identities are in dispute relative to each other.

All labels observed (9)

Label Occurrences
disputedIdentification 12
hasDisputedIdentityWith canonical 8
debatedIdentification 4

Description generation (PDg)

The one-sentence description above was generated by prompting gpt-5.1 with the predicate name and this instruction.

Instruction
Given a predicate that represents a relationship or action between entities, generate a one-sentence description explaining its meaning.  
# Instructions
Focus on describing the relationship, not the entities themselves. 
# Response Format
Begin the description with \' Indicates...\'
Input
Predicate: hasDisputedIdentityWith
Generated description
Indicates that two entities are associated with conflicting, uncertain, or contested identifications, such that their true or correct identities are in dispute relative to each other.

Sample triples (35)

Subject Object
Prince William of Orange (disputed) William I of Orange
surface form: William I, Prince of Orange
Prince William of Orange (disputed) William II, Prince of Orange
Prince William of Orange (disputed) William III of England
surface form: William III of Orange
Prince William of Orange (disputed) William IV, Prince of Orange
Prince William of Orange (disputed) William V, Prince of Orange
Prince William of Orange (disputed) William I of the Netherlands
Prince William of Orange (disputed) William II of the Netherlands
Prince William of Orange (disputed) William III of the Netherlands
John
surface form: John of Patmos
Apostle John via predicate surface "disputedIdentificationWith"
surface form: John the Apostle
John
surface form: John of Patmos
Apostle John via predicate surface "disputedIdentificationWith"
surface form: John the Evangelist
Lapis Niger royal memorial via predicate surface "debatedIdentification"
Lapis Niger altar of a deity via predicate surface "debatedIdentification"
Lapis Niger cenotaph or symbolic tomb via predicate surface "debatedIdentification"
Jebel Musa location of biblical Mount Sinai via predicate surface "disputedIdentification"
Aha Narmer via predicate surface "disputedIdentification"
surface form: Menes
Aha Narmer via predicate surface "disputedIdentification"
surface form: Narmer (alternative candidate for Menes)
Erlitou site capital of the Xia dynasty via predicate surface "debatedIdentification"
King Ergamenes exact correspondence with Arkamani I via predicate surface "disputedIdentification"
Sir John Oldcastle (name only, disputed)
surface form: Sir John Oldcastle
Sir John Falstaff via predicate surface "hasDisputedConnectionWith"
surface form: Shakespearean character Sir John Falstaff
Taricheae (possible identification in some scholarly views)
surface form: Taricheae
Magdala via predicate surface "disputedIdentification"
Bunjevci Croats via predicate surface "disputedIdentityWith"
Bunjevci Serbs via predicate surface "disputedIdentityWith"
King David’s Tomb complex actual burial place of King David via predicate surface "disputedIdentification"
Sanakhte equation with Nebka via predicate surface "disputedIdentification"
Large Stone Structure Palace of King David via predicate surface "disputedIdentification" NERFINISHED
Love's Labour's Won (lost play)
surface form: Love's Labour's Won
Much Ado About Nothing via predicate surface "hasDebatedIdentityWith" NERFINISHED
Love's Labour's Won (lost play)
surface form: Love's Labour's Won
The Taming of the Shrew via predicate surface "hasDebatedIdentityWith" NERFINISHED
Love's Labour's Won (lost play)
surface form: Love's Labour's Won
All's Well That Ends Well via predicate surface "hasDebatedIdentityWith" NERFINISHED
Jacob's Pillow Stone Stone of Scone via predicate surface "hasDebatedIdentificationWith" NERFINISHED
Jacob's Pillow Stone Lia Fáil via predicate surface "hasDebatedIdentificationWith" NERFINISHED
Calisia true via predicate surface "disputedIdentification"
Alesia alternative proposed locations in France via predicate surface "disputedIdentification"
Salem some scholars question equation with Jerusalem via predicate surface "disputedIdentification"
Wanderer Melanie Stryder via predicate surface "hasConflictingIdentityWith" NERFINISHED
At-Tur exact historical location of Mount Sinai via predicate surface "disputedIdentification"