Volcanic Seven Summits (alternative definition debates)

E609137

geographical classification debate list-definition dispute mountaineering controversy

The Volcanic Seven Summits (alternative definition debates) refers to the ongoing discussion among mountaineers and geographers over which volcanic peaks should officially count as the highest on each continent, leading to competing summit lists.

Try in SPARQL Jump to: Surface forms Statements Referenced by

All labels observed (2)

Label	Occurrences
Volcanic Seven Summits	1
Volcanic Seven Summits (alternative definition debates) canonical	1

Statements (44)

Predicate	Object
instanceOf	geographical classification debate ⓘ list-definition dispute ⓘ mountaineering controversy ⓘ
arisesFrom	different definitions of what constitutes a volcano ⓘ different interpretations of tectonic and geographic boundaries ⓘ different interpretations of topographic prominence requirements ⓘ different interpretations of volcanic activity status ⓘ lack of universally accepted definition of continents ⓘ
concerns	criteria for defining continental high points ⓘ highest volcanic peak on each continent ⓘ selection of qualifying volcanoes ⓘ
hasAspect	comparison with Seven Summits definition disputes ⓘ competing summit lists ⓘ impact on climbers’ completion claims ⓘ impact on commercial expedition marketing ⓘ impact on record recognition ⓘ variation in accepted peak lists among authors ⓘ
hasConsequence	existence of multiple recognized Volcanic Seven Summits lists ⓘ need for climbers to specify which list they follow ⓘ ongoing academic and popular discussion about continental definitions ⓘ variation in what counts as completing the Volcanic Seven Summits challenge ⓘ
hasTopic	Volcanic Seven Summits NERFINISHED ⓘ
includesIssue	how to handle complex volcanic massifs with multiple summits ⓘ treatment of Antarctic volcanic high points ⓘ treatment of island volcanoes relative to continental landmasses ⓘ whether subsidiary volcanic cones can qualify ⓘ whether to count Mount Damavand as a European or Asian volcano ⓘ whether to count Mount Elbrus or Mount Etna for Europe ⓘ whether to prioritize elevation over prominence ⓘ whether to require clear volcanic origin for the summit ⓘ whether to treat the Caucasus as part of Europe or Asia ⓘ whether to use Australia or Australasia as the continental unit ⓘ whether to use Australia or Oceania as the continental unit ⓘ which peak is the highest volcano in Oceania ⓘ
involvesCommunity	geographers ⓘ guidebook authors ⓘ mountaineers ⓘ peak-baggers ⓘ record-keeping organizations ⓘ
relatedTo	Seven Summits (mountaineering challenge) NERFINISHED ⓘ continental high point lists ⓘ mountaineering ethics and claims ⓘ volcano classification ⓘ
timePeriod	late 20th century to present ⓘ

Referenced by (2)

Full triples — surface form annotated when it differs from this entity's canonical label.

Puncak Jaya → isPartOfList → Volcanic Seven Summits (alternative definition debates) ⓘ

Uhuru Peak → isOnList → Volcanic Seven Summits (alternative definition debates) ⓘ

this entity surface form: Volcanic Seven Summits